Drawing in René Descartes' (1596-1650) "Treatise of Man" explaining the function of the pineal gland.
Thoughts exist. They don't exist in the material world, but they do exist somewhere. Thoughts are real. Thoughts are.
And what about feelings? Feelings are not the same as thoughts. You can feel happy without thinking of happiness. You can feel happy without thinking about being happy, or about whether the happiness is warranted, or about where the feeling of happiness comes from. Feelings don’t exist in the material world. But they do exist. Feelings are real. Feelings are. It’s unclear whether feelings exist in the same world as thoughts, or in another, non-material world.
Emotions: are they the same as feelings? Are emotions thoughts? Where do emotions exist?